Ethnizität, Akkulturation und persönliche Netzwerke
Leverkusen, Barbara Budrich-Verlag 2008.
English Summary Ethnicity, Acculturation, and Personal Networks of Italian Migrants
The study applies an interactionist theoretical perspective to the case of migrant cultures and
tests it with data from a survey of Italian migrants in Stuttgart, Germany.
The first part reconstructs the interactionist perspective in sociology. Arguments from
Symbolic Interactionism and the Chicago School, from Norbert Elias’s Figurational
Sociology, and from the theory of social networks of Harrison White and others are drawn
together and condensed to an interactionist view of collective identities. According to this
perspective, social structure is shaped in the interplay of interaction structures and symbolic
patterns and categories. This relational and phenomenological understanding of social
structure is related to the new discourse on social inequalities by reformulating the concepts
of life-style, milieu, and subculture. The fundamental conjectures are:
1. Meaning is anchored in social networks and structures these.
2. Network contexts differ in their cultural imprint. These different socio-cultural contexts can
3. Social categories are an important aspect of the level of meaning in networks. They map
networks and structure them in return. Subcultures feature strong and salient categories as
boundaries between themselves and their social environments.
These conjectures are applied to the case of migrant cultures in the second part. Ethnicity is
viewed as a social category along criteria of descent, differentiating ethnic groups from one
another. Migrant cultures are a special instance of subcultures because of their origins in
migration processes. Cultural difference is thus imported into the receiving contexts. Migrant
cultures center on the tension between sending and receiving context. The personal contacts
of migrants are a crucial factor for the ways in which they cope with this tension. Migrants
with many personal relationships to members of the receiving context (high social
assimilation) are expected to show more acculturation and less salience of the ethnic identity.
This interactionist perspective is contrasted with the economic perspective on migrant cultues
as developed by Hartmut Esser. Esser starts from the assumption that socio-economic
attainment is the decisive dimension of the assimilation process. These two alternative
perspectives on migrant cultures are condensed into competing hypotheses which are tested
with data from a survey on Italian migrants in Stuttgart, Germany.
The hypotheses are tested in multivariate statistical procedures (such as partial correlations,
OLS- and Logit-regressions), controlling for sex, migrant generation and the educational level
in Italy. Social assimilation is measured as the proportion of non-Italian alteri named as
important by the respondents, socio-economic assimilation as the cultural and economic
capital available in the receiving context (education in Germany and income). The most
important results of the empirical analysis are:
1. Acculturation (measured as the respondents’ religiosity and their tolerance for divorce,
abortion and homosexuality) chiefly depends on social assimilation. Socio-economic
attainment only influences tolerance (not religiosity) and less so than ethnic contacts.
2. The salience of ethnic identity is analyzed on two dimensions: the subjective placement
between sending and receiving context, and the more concrete alienation from the sending
context. Alienation primarily depends on the social assimilation and not on socio-economic
attainment. The subjective placement, in contrast, is mostly independent of both dimensions
and seems to be represent a merely symbolic ethnicity.
3. Linguistic practice and social assimilation are strongly coupled. A direct influence from
socio-economic to social assimilation (as suggested by Esser) is hardly identifiable. Rather, an
indirect influence through the linguistic practices exists. Language works as ‘practical
ethnicity’ in the migrant culture studied. The boundary between the migrant culture and the
receiving context is drawn on the basis of language.
Overall, the empirical results support the interactionist perspective on migrant cultures. The
hypotheses from the economic perspective, in contrast, are mostly falsified. The successful
integration of migrants thus depends chiefly on the establishment of personal relationships to
members of the receiving context, and on the learning and practicing of their language.
LE BULLETIN DU NEPTUNE - N°17 MERCREDI 28 JANVIER 2008 Grand Concours Retour le règlement Nous vous rappelons que le NCF organise un grand concours sur la natation dont le premier prix est une combinaison de natation de marque Speedo (ou un iPod au choix du lauréat). Chaque semaine une question est publiée dans le bulletin. Le lauréat est celui qui aura répondu
Revia Karl, a frail, 84-year-old woman is living her last years in a psychotic haze in an Inglewood, California hospital. So she doesn’t know that her grandson ran through most of her $75,000 in life savings after a court appointed him her conservator. In Washington D.C., an attorney acting as conservator took $376,000 from an elderly man’s estate. He later pleaded guilty to fraud